I
f it were a bag of crisps, the mod-
ern line array would probably be
a packet of cheese and onion –
the choice of a nation, apparently –
while cluster technology would be
more like salt and vinegar. Everyone
knows that that salt and vinegar has
a clean, biting taste that often blows
your socks off, while not everyone
is sure why they like cheese and
onion, they just do. Ultimately, they
end up being eaten without people
really thinking about it.
The first incarnation of the basic
science behind modern systems
appeared in the late 1950s and com-
monly consisted of four, eight-inch
drivers. It was found that this verti-
cal configuration gave wide hori-
zontal and tight vertical coverage,
yet was unfortunately frequency-
dependent. These systems were
installed in schools, churches and
bars around the world; their clean
mid-range making the intelligibility
of vocals excellent. As rock n roll
dawned and required more power
handing from loudspeaker systems,
the columns slowly disappeared
from view.
Then, in 1984 Dr Christian Heil
set-up C.Heil TEA, later renamed L-
Acoustics (a move that was to please
his future marketing staff no end).
In 1992 the company was granted
patents for its DOSC waveguide,
which was quickly followed by the
introduction of the V-DOSC system
in May 1993. The rest, as they say,
is history.
Chris Fitch, director of Skan PA
[ 52] March 2005
LINE ARRAYS
sr
Flavour of
the
moment?
Clever marketing, blind faith or
misunderstanding? Rob Speight looks at the
current state of line arrays and wonders
and user of V-DOSC, explains,
“Christian Heil – he convinced a
few people and it snow-balled from
there. As he is the first to admit, line
array is not the only solution, but it
is one that (non-technical) pur-
chasers can understand – it is easy
to spot a vertical line of cabinets. It
is harder to spot whether it is actu-
ally a good system, so ‘line array’
has become a sort of short-hand for
‘high-quality modern system’.”
With so much universal accept-
ance, the line array developed its
own groupies in the form of the pro-
audio manufacturing business. >> HK Audio’s Cohedra line array
>>It is almost impossible to find a
major player which does not have
its own flavour – everyone from
DAS to d&b, EAW to Electro-Voice,
Martin Audio to Meyer Sound – the
list is almost endless.
“If I’m 100% honest, I’d say that
this is a combination of product
capability, hype, economics and, by
many other manufacturers, panic,”
said Tim McCall of Turbosound,
whose recently released Aspect sys-
tem is starting to cause a stir. (Turbo,
of course, resolutely defies to con-
form to the line array trend – so far).
Paul Nunnington, product mar-
keting manager at Sennheiser UK,
distributor of Adamson’s Y-Axis and
SpekTrix systems, has different
ideas. “It is because the technology
has brought to the fore the deficien-
cies of previous mechanically
arrayed loudspeakers,” he said. This
indeed may be true, and in certain
circles the line array is often per-
ceived as the cure to all audio ills.
Over-simplified this may be, untrue
it certainly is and it is something
manufacturers are the first to admit.
Giorgio Biffi of Italian manufac-
turer Outline told us, “Line array,
even our ‘Butterfly’, is not the
answer to all sound reinforcement.
We feel that each project should be
looked at closely. For instance, in the
last couple of months we have
installed many churches, theatres
and concert halls, and these projects
required ‘Butterfly’ to achieve opti-
mum results.
“However, at Outline we look at
each job individually and will give
our clients the best advice, which
may conclude in using a trapezoidal
cabinet. But in live performances
such as festivals where long throw
and perfect horizontal control is
needed, we will recommend
‘Butterfly’ Outline array.”
In the scheme of things, it is not
the purveyors of the technology that
extol the virtue and perfection of the
line array solution, everyone knows
what a bad engineer or an acousti-
cally troubled venue can do. Asking
the High Priest Of Purple, Tony
Andrews of Funktion One, about a
line array is akin to lighting a long,
slow-burning fuse on a softly spo-
ken bomb. “Commercial firms are
going to spot a bandwagon and get
on it – that is all they have done,
really. They wouldn’t have done it if
there weren’t a demand or an accept-
ance. It is even hard to analyse why
the live industry has taken it up. It
doesn’t seem to matter about audio
quality as long as it is a line array.
One of the things about this situa-
tion is that it is not that revealing.
You can get away with, shall we say,
inadequate mixing because it is all a
mush. About three years ago an
engineer, I won’t mention who it
was, said about our systems ‘I can’t
use this, it is too revealing’.”
Yet, line arrays or even technol-
ogy purporting to be line arrays are
now deeply ingrained in the live
sound and touring market, and the
trend has transformed into main-
stream fashion. Even Heil himself
told PSNE, “I agree that line array
technology is excessively popular
and has now reached non-rational
levels of interest. It seems that the
line source concept is used as a way
to solve any sound design problem,
even when there are better alterna-
tives. I am not sure that the manu-
facturers are fully responsible for
this situation but they have cer-
tainly taken advantage of it. I think
the vehicle of this belief is multiple,
can be found among the users, the
artists and promoters, the venue
owners as well as the designers and
manufacturers.”
Every loudspeaker system, line
array or not, will have its own
advantages and disadvantages in dif-
ferent situations such as venue, audi-
ence size, coverage, flying facilities,
rig time and cost – the list is endless.
“Compared to normal array sys-
tems, line arrays particularly show
their strengths in large-scale sound
reinforcement applications,”
Christian Stumpp of HK Audio says.
“First and most importantly, true
line arrays are able to deliver the full
frequency range in a very clear way
up to the FOH position and beyond.
In the beginning, this was one of the
major surprises for touring engineers
– suddenly they could really hear
everything they were mixing.
“Secondly, they have a big han-
dling advantage over standard sys-
tems – faster rigging, less rigging
points, less time needed for load in
and out and sometimes less space in
the truck. For a touring company,
this can mean a higher return on
investment.”
T
he cure-all beliefs of some are,
it would seem, emanating from
the less technically aware, a new
breed of engineer who knows how
to operate the system set-up and
configuration software, but without
the practical, hands-on knowledge
and experience to know what piece
of kit to use where. “Certainly, there
are many instances where line arrays
have been shoe-horned into situations
where other approaches would have
worked better. But it is usually not
the audio professionals forcing things.
It is usually a less knowledgeable
>>
March 2005 [ 53]
LINE ARRAYS
sr
2/5 ad
Grouped stacked Adamson systems
Outline Butterfly
>> customer who thinks he has to
insist on a line array to make sure
he gets the latest technology,” Dave
Gunness, director of research and
development for EAW concurs.
Recalling a gig several years ago,
Chris Beale of SSE Hire (with an
inventory of JBL VerTec and Nexo
GEO S and T systems) says, “Part
of the problem is that so many
bands are absolutely committed to
the idea of using a line array and
that they will go and take them into
a university or something like that.
About three years ago we went, with
a very well known engineer, into a
show with V-DOSC. The itinerary
included arenas and then one of the
shows was in Leeds University,
which is little more than a dining
room. The first thing I said at the
time was not to take a line array in
there, just abandon it and we will
deliver a Nexo Alpha system that
will do the job great. The engineer
declined and said he wouldn’t want
to do it unless he was mixing on his
V-DOSC system and preceded to
have the most catastrophic gig of his
life. All he was doing was mixing off
a massive reflection, the whole place
was resonating like a tin box.”
It soon became apparent that the
daddies of the line array world –V-
DOSC, Meyer Sounds M3D, VerTec
and EAW KF760s for example —
were not suitable for the type of
smaller venues Beale outlines. So the
manufacturers responded with the
launch of what is essentially the sec-
ond generation of the technology:
the baby, compact or mini arrays. In
only the last few months, in fact,
we’ve seen the number of products
in this genre expand: JBL launched
the VRX932LA, E-V its XL Very
Compact system, HK Audio the
Cohedra Compact, and Meyer Sound
has added even more mid-sized venue
possibilities for its MILO system with
the MILO 60, bringing MILO fami-
ly membership up to three.
Paul Timmins, project manager
for Capital Sound Hire, explained,
“The problem for us now as a com-
pany is that everyone wants line
array. For theatre touring its mid-
size, for summer work and arenas
obviously it’s the larger boxes. Also
we have a pile of conventional PA
now that no one wants to use. You
can use it on budget stuff. Then you
have the touring periods of late win-
ter and later on in the year where the
mid-sized boxes are the cabinets to
go with; then, come the summer, we
will have those sat in the warehouse
and we will have the larger boxes
out. So, the biggest difference for
rental companies is that before, with
conventional systems, it would be
pretty flexible. You would have a
load of boxes and you would pix and
mix. Now, you have to be pretty
shrewd in what you buy because the
use of the boxes is pretty seasonal.”
Logic System are a company to
take a slightly different approach to
the smaller system. Aimed primari-
ly at the small to medium sized ven-
ues and hire companies, Logic
System developed their ETHOS
array. Designed to enable the same
level of technology used at large
shows with big budgets, ETHOS is
intended to be accessible by more of
the market. “We perceived a need in
the market, but we came up with a
different slant on it. We didn’t come
up with a 50-box flying J, instead
we came up with a 20-
box system that would fit in
the back of a Sprinter van. Also,
ETHOS is primarily designed to
allow it to ground-stack as well as
fly,” Logic’s Andy Simmons
explained.
N
ow, with the recent announce-
ment of the L-Acoustics
KUDO system, the next generation
has started to appear. Beale explains,
“Line arrays in their original con-
cept were cylindrical output devices;
they were designed to create a cylin-
drical output that addressed the ver-
tical topology of the room. But they
never addressed the horizontal
topology. The horizontal control and
the horizontal coupling were com-
pletely ignored. That, of course, is a
more technical problem and more
complex, but everyone has conve-
niently chosen to forget it.”
The KUDO, with its vertical and
horizontal line source array config-
urations, together with the new
adjustable K-Louver waveguide,
would certainly seem to be a step in
the right direction. Horizontal direc-
tivity is obviously something that
more than one manufacturer is look-
ing to address.
“We see a combination of elec-
tronic beam steering and line source
as the next big thing. Picture a
small, self-powered, conventional-
looking trapezoidal loudspeaker
comprised of four or five line
source elements that can be
mechanically adjusted by the aver-
age band member [perish the
thought]. We believe the technolo-
gy can go anywhere with the right
vision,” enthuses Paul Nunnington.
All technology development is a
continuous process and perfection
is something to strive for. In the
world of live sound, and especially
touring sound, the most perfect
loudspeaker in the planet will never
be able to completely overcome
>>
[ 54] March 2005
LINE ARRAYS
sr
2/5 ad
d&b Q Series
JBL VerTec system: midsized version now available
>> the imperfections of most venues,
let alone engineers. “The develop-
ment of line array technology is far
from finished,” concluded Beale.
So what of the future? EAW’s
Dave Gunness again: “New line
array models will continue to be
introduced until every manufactur-
er has a product in every market
niche. Of course, you could say the
same about loudspeakers in gener-
al. In the next few years though, I
think you’ll see some of the indus-
try’s innovative energies directed in
more diverse directions again.”
Many see a push into the theatre
and installation market by the com-
pact systems, the acceptance level
and usage currently being on the
smaller side. Conferences are prob-
ably an excellently suited market; a
good example of this was the use, by
both Bush and Kerry in the US elec-
tions, of a JBL VerTec system during
their campaigns. This is along simi-
lar lines expressed by Heil: “I think
there are other places other than live
performance where effective line
source technology would make
sense, especially in the field of speech
reinforcement in places where the
sound performance is very poor and
unacceptable in terms of safety such
as airports and train stations.”
While it is undeniable that the
basis of the technology is here to
stay, it’s concluding development
may well be someway off. “The holy
grail is a system which has all the
advantages of a line array, but in the
horizontal as well as the vertical
plane,” envisions d&b audiotech-
nik’s Michael Cooper, echoing Chris
Beale’s words.
So it is probably safe to say that the
line array is more like a multi-pack of
your favourite crisp. Put lots of them
together of different flavours and
everybody wants one, there are nor-
mally more than enough to go round,
and they are individually wrapped for
quality. Where as the more tradition-
al loudspeaker technology is a large
grab bag of the flavour of your choice
— easy to get at, easy to swallow…
and the bag makes a really big noise
when you burst it.
Or in the words of Turbosound’s
Tim McCall, “In our view, line
arrays are a very useful tool. But
while you can use a flat head screw-
driver with Posidrive screws, it’s not
always successful.” []
[ 56] March 2005
LINE ARRAYS
sr
3/5 ad
Contacts
CONTACT >> L-ACOUSTICS
TEL >> +33 (0) 1 69 63 69 63
EMAIL >> info@l-acoustics.com
CONTACT >> SKAN PA
TEL >> +44 (0)118 975 5088
EMAIL >> enquiries@skanpa.co.uk
CONTACT >> DAS
TEL >> +34 96 134 0860
EMAIL >> sales@dasaudio.com
CONTACT >> EAW
TEL >> +1 508 234 6158
EMAIL >> sales@eaw.com
CONTACT >> ELECTRO-VOICE
TEL >> +1 952 884 4051
EMAIL >> pro.sound@telex.com
CONTACT >> HK AUDIO
TEL >> +49 (0) 68 51 9050
EMAIL >> info@hkaudio.com
CONTACT >> JBL
TEL >> +1 818 830 7801
EMAIL >> sales@harmanprouk.com
CONTACT >> LOGIC SYSTEM
TEL >> +44 (0)1427 611 791
EMAIL >> sales@logic-system.co.uk
CONTACT >> MARTIN AUDIO
TEL >> +1 519 747 5853
EMAIL >> sales@martin-audio.com
CONTACT >> MEYER SOUND
TEL >> +1 510 486 1166
CONTACT >> NEXO
TEL >> +33 148 63 19 14
EMAIL >> info@nexo.fr
CONTACT >> OUTLINE
TEL >> +39 030 35 81 341
EMAIL >> info@outline.it
CONTACT >> RENKUS-HEINZ
TEL >> +46 8 544 725 88
EMAIL >> sille@renkus-heinz.com
CONTACT >> D&B AUDIOTECHNIK
TEL >> +49 7191 96690
EMAIL >> info@dbaudio.com
CONTACT >> TURBOSOUND
TEL >> +44 1403 711447
CONTACT >> ADAMSON
TEL >> +1 905 982 0520
EMAIL >> sales@adamsonproaudio.com
CONTACT >> FUNKTION ONE
TEL >> +44 (0)1306 712820
CONTACT >> SSE HIRE
TEL >> +44 (0)152 752 88 22
CONTACT >> CAPITAL SOUND HIRE
TEL >> +44 (0)20 8944 6777
Renkus Heinz boxes