Is podcasting eating itself?

Or what is podcasting in 2026?

It started as a simple idea, announced to the world by Steve Jobs back in June 2005 – the iPod would support this burgeoning medium.

Starting in basements and kitchens around the world, podcasting was, on the whole, dire. But it was freedom to get an opinion or a silly idea out to the masses, or in most cases, to a few of your mates and the occasional nerd.

Podcasting was adopted fairly quickly as an on-demand version of broadcast radio. Shows are putting out cut-down versions online. Notably, in the UK, Chris Moyles’s breakfast show on BBC Radio 1 was only the best bits from the week, with all the music removed (for licensing reasons). At the other end of the spectrum was The Ricky Gervais podcast, which moved from XFM to The Guardian in 2005 and was awarded a Guinness World Record for over 18 million downloads at the time. As of March 2011, the podcast has been downloaded over 300 million times.

What was it that made that show so successful? Was it the high production value? Not really, it was, of course, the hosts and irreverent humour.

But it was simple, cost-effective and content-rich.

So where are we today? We have the likes of Joe Rogan, Diary of a CEO with Stephen Bartlett, and The Tucker Carlson Show. These are all, and at the risk of being shot down in flames, not really podcasts, are they? They are cheap TV shows, and in my opinion, unnecessarily so.

What is the advantage of putting two men in a room chatting in a video format? Do I care that Joe Rogan can keep his headphones on his incredibly shiny head for three hours without them slipping off?

Do I want to see Stephen Bartlett smugly smiling or pretending he’s dumb about something that even the most low-hanging fruit of a listener understands?

And let’s not even talk about Tucker Carlson!

The point is, these shows do not need to be on video. If anything, that reduces their listenership. I can’t watch a video podcast (or whatever the hell you call them) in my car, and why do I want to watch a tiny screen of a bald man balancing headphones on the train?

We’re at a point where everyone wants a podcast, and everybody thinks they need video. Why? It costs more, it takes more bandwidth (both data-wise and engagement-wise), and it begs the question: Is it so hard to listen to naked audio?

Many people will say they ‘listen’ to podcasts while they’re cleaning the house, making dinner, or falling asleep. So why do they need video?

Production companies are confused, creators are confused, post-production workflows and workers are confused, and frankly, The Podcast Show is totally confused.

The Podcast Show needs to ask itself, what is it, because right now the overarching theme is ad sales, big-budget shows that need sponsors and corporations to be there because they feel they need to be.

The Podcast Show has no soul. I spoke to several people who were generally confused about the event’s usefulness. “I take some pictures, talk to a few people and get pissed.” It’s not even really networking because it’s all too cliquey.

The most useful part of the Podcast Show, apart from the steps outside the Business Design Centre, which seem to be perpetually in the sun, is the networking tables (which you can book and use to talk to random people you find on the app).

There needs to be more of this. Fewer companies desperately trying to find a sponsor for the next shiny-headed host-based talk show, more actual producers and creators (both sides of the microphone/camera) talking, sharing, and trying to understand what this rapidly expanding corporate blob of an industry really is!